Sardines for Beginners · Mild Brands · Keto Mediterranean
Best Sardines for Beginners:
Mild Brands That Don’t Taste Fishy
If you’ve tried sardines once and decided you hate them, you probably had the wrong brand. Here are the six mildest options and exactly how to start eating them without the experience you’re dreading.
⚠️ Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through my links I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I have personally tried or researched thoroughly.
Most people who think they hate sardines have only tried one brand, once, probably straight from a tin that smelled alarming, eaten out of obligation rather than desire. That is not a fair trial. That is the sardine equivalent of deciding you hate wine after drinking warm boxed rosé at a college party.
Sardines vary enormously by brand, origin, packing medium and processing method. The difference between a tin of King Oscar in olive oil and a generic supermarket tin in brine is not subtle — they taste like different foods. The mild ones are genuinely pleasant for people who don’t think of themselves as fish eaters. The strong ones are an acquired taste that even some confirmed sardine lovers find intense.
This post starts with the mildest and works toward the bolder. If you are completely new to sardines, start with number one and give yourself three or four tries before deciding anything.
“The best sardine for a beginner is not the one with the best omega-3 profile or the most sustainable sourcing. It is the one you will actually eat.”
Why some sardines taste fishy and others don’t
The “fishy” flavour most people associate with sardines comes from trimethylamine (TMA) — a compound produced when bacteria break down trimethylamine oxide (TMAO) in fish tissue after catch. The faster the fish is processed and tinned after catching, the less TMA develops, and the milder the flavour. This is why freshness-at-processing matters more than the species.
Four factors determine how mild a canned sardine tastes:
Origin and species: Norwegian brisling sardines (small, cold-water fish) are naturally milder than large Mediterranean sardines. Portuguese sardines fall in between — firm and flavourful but not aggressive. Spanish sardines tend to be the boldest.
Packing medium: Olive oil buffers and softens the flavour. Spring water is neutral but lets the fish flavour come through fully. Brine (salt water) can amplify intensity. Tomato sauce or mustard add their own flavours that can clash. For beginners: olive oil first.
Size: Smaller sardines are milder. “Brisling” sardines (Norwegian small sprat) are consistently the gentlest entry point. Larger Mediterranean sardines are more intensely flavoured.
Age in the tin: Sardines actually mellow and improve with age — like a wine that needs time. A tin that’s been sitting for a year or two is often noticeably smoother than a fresh one. This is not a concern when buying from Amazon or a good deli; it’s more relevant if you find a very recent pack date from a new production run.
Flavour intensity — all 6 brands ranked
The 6 brands reviewed
King Oscar is the one I give to people who are convinced they hate sardines. The brisling sprat used by King Oscar is smaller and younger than true Mediterranean sardines, which makes them naturally milder and more delicate. Packed in EVOO, they have a clean, almost sweet flavour that tastes nothing like the strong canned sardines most people have encountered.
They’re also visually more appealing for beginners — small, uniform, firm fish rather than the larger, more rustic appearance of Mediterranean varieties. If someone is reluctant about sardines, presentation matters. King Oscar presents well.
The one note: because they’re small brisling rather than true sardines, the omega-3 content per tin is slightly lower than larger Mediterranean varieties. You’d need to eat a few more tins per week to hit the same EPA/DHA dose. For a first tin, this doesn’t matter — the priority is getting you eating them at all.
Bela is where beginners go after King Oscar wins them over. Portuguese sardines have a slightly more developed flavour than Norwegian brisling — you can actually taste that you’re eating fish, but it’s pleasant rather than intense. The texture is firmer and the fish holds together better, which makes them easier to work with in salads and on top of vegetables.
Bela’s production is well-regarded — hand-packed, Atlantic-caught, processed quickly. The olive oil quality is decent, which matters for a keto Mediterranean approach where you’re eating the packing oil as part of the dish.
Season in spring water is the closest thing to canned tuna in the sardine world — firm, neutral, mild, very easy to eat. If you approach it expecting tuna, it tastes like a slightly richer version of what you already know. If you approach it expecting sardines, it will seem surprisingly inoffensive.
The water-packed version is lower in calories and fat than olive oil-packed options, which makes it useful if you’re eating sardines primarily for the protein and omega-3 rather than the additional fat. For a keto Mediterranean approach, I’d still recommend olive oil-packed most of the time — but Season in water is a genuinely good beginner option, especially if you’re sensitive to oily textures.
Wild Planet is the brand that graduates beginners into confident sardine eaters. The flavour is noticeably more developed than King Oscar or Bela — this is what sardines actually taste like when you’re eating them as a proper food rather than a tentative introduction. Clean, full, oceanic without being aggressive.
Wild Planet is my daily tin. The quality and consistency are excellent — firm fish, good oil, no off-notes. They’re also MSC-certified sustainable and packed in genuine EVOO, which matters when you’re eating the packing oil as part of the nutritional profile. The omega-3 content per tin is higher than brisling varieties.
Matiz is for the beginner who went to Wild Planet and found they actually liked it and wants to understand what all the fuss is about with Spanish sardines. Galician sardines from the Rias Baixas have a distinctly Mediterranean character — richer, more savoury, with a depth that King Oscar doesn’t have. They taste like they belong in a Mediterranean kitchen.
The presentation is beautiful — hand-packed, uniform fish, good oil. This is the tin you’d take to a picnic or open in front of guests without apology.
Crown Prince is on this list for completeness and budget value — not as a beginner recommendation. These are larger fish in spring water with a full, bold sardine flavour. Experienced sardine eaters love them. Beginners who try Crown Prince first often conclude sardines are not for them, which would be the wrong conclusion.
If you’ve worked through the list and found you like Wild Planet and Matiz, Crown Prince is worth trying for everyday budget use. The price per tin is significantly lower and the nutritional profile is strong. For beginners: please start with King Oscar.
How to actually start eating sardines
The tin is open. The sardines are in front of you. Here is the actual protocol for someone who is genuinely new and slightly uncertain.
Week 1: Hide them completely
Don’t eat them plain yet. Open a tin of King Oscar, drain it, and fork the fish into a bowl of Greek salad — tomatoes, cucumber, feta, olives, lots of EVOO and lemon. The sardines provide protein and omega-3; the other ingredients provide most of what you taste. You’re not really eating sardines yet. You’re eating a Greek salad that happens to contain sardines.
Week 2: Let them be present
Mash half a tin with half an avocado, add a squeeze of lemon, salt and pepper, and spread on cucumber rounds. Now you can taste the sardines slightly, but the avocado and lemon are still dominant. This is how you get your palate used to the flavour without it feeling confrontational.
Week 3: Eat them cooked
Pan-fry a drained tin in a hot cast iron pan for 90 seconds per side with sliced garlic. Add lemon zest and oregano off the heat. Eat over arugula with EVOO. Cooked sardines taste genuinely different from tinned — more complex, less tinny, more like a proper meal. This is often where people stop thinking of sardines as something they’re tolerating and start thinking of them as something they want.
4 beginner meals that work for first-timers
Greek Salad + Sardines
Tomatoes, cucumber, feta, olives, red onion, EVOO, lemon. Fork in a drained tin of King Oscar. Toss. The sardines disappear into the salad — you taste Greek salad with extra substance.
Avocado + Sardine Mash
Half a ripe avocado mashed with half a tin of sardines, lemon juice, salt, chilli flakes. Serve on cucumber rounds or lettuce cups. The avocado fat coats the palate and makes the fish taste mild and creamy.
Pan-Fried with Garlic
Drain, pat dry, fry 90 seconds each side in avocado oil. Off heat: lemon zest, oregano, chilli flakes. Serve over arugula. This is where sardines become a proper dinner rather than a nutritional exercise.
Mediterranean Sardine Salad
The full version — capers, olives, tomatoes, feta, ladolemono dressing. Three recipe variations. This is the one you make for guests and don’t apologise for.
Frequently Asked Questions
What sardines don’t taste fishy?
King Oscar in olive oil is the mildest widely available option — Norwegian brisling sprat with a clean, almost sweet flavour. Bela (Portuguese) and Season in spring water are close seconds. The key factors: smaller fish, olive oil packing, Atlantic or Norwegian origin, quick processing after catch. Avoid generic supermarket brands in brine as a starting point — these are typically the strongest-tasting options.
How do I start eating sardines if I don’t like fish?
Start with King Oscar in olive oil, drained and mixed into a Greek salad with strong competing flavours — feta, olives, lemon, cucumber. Don’t eat them straight from the tin your first time. Give yourself three separate occasions before deciding anything. The first try is always partly about processing unfamiliarity, not just taste. By the third try you’re actually tasting the food.
What is the mildest canned sardine?
King Oscar in olive oil, consistently. The Norwegian brisling sprat used by King Oscar are smaller, younger and milder than true Mediterranean sardines. Packed in EVOO, they taste closer to a mild tinned fish than to the strong sardine flavour most people dread. Bela in olive oil is a close second.
Should I start with sardines in water or oil?
Olive oil for most beginners. Water-packed sardines let the fish flavour come through more fully without anything to buffer it. Olive oil softens and rounds the flavour. The exception: if you’re very sensitive to oily textures, Season in spring water has a firmer, more tuna-like texture that some people find easier to start with.
Are sardines in olive oil healthier than in water?
Neither is inherently healthier — it depends what you’re optimising for. Sardines in olive oil provide more total fat and calories, but the added fat is beneficial oleic acid. The sardine’s omega-3 content is identical regardless of packing medium. For a keto Mediterranean approach, olive oil-packed is preferred — the EVOO adds oleocanthal and the richer flavour makes the meal more satisfying.
How often should beginners eat sardines?
Start with once a week for the first month while you build the habit and find the preparation you like. Then move to twice a week — the research threshold for meaningful omega-3 health benefits. Eventually three times a week is the Mediterranean-diet target. There’s no upper limit on frequency for canned sardines; they’re very low in mercury and can be eaten daily without concern.
The progression, simplified
King Oscar → Bela → Wild Planet. That is the beginner arc for most people — mild, then flavourful, then genuinely good. Three or four tins across a few weeks, approached the right way, and most people who thought they didn’t like sardines find out they were wrong.
The stakes are low. A tin costs less than a coffee. The worst outcome is that you don’t like them and you’ve confirmed something you already suspected. The best outcome is that you’ve found the most convenient, affordable, nutritionally complete anti-inflammatory food available, and you’ve been avoiding it your whole life for no good reason.
Start with King Oscar. Give it three tries. Then come back and tell me I was wrong.